A collection of writing, songs, poems by Ken King. More words will be added soon, so please keep checking in.
As the 20th century draws to a close it is natural to be thinking about time, a subject which has both fascinated and perplexed thinkers since the beginning of—whatever it is. Augustine said that he knew what time was as long as no one asked him to explain. Charles Lamb wrote that “nothing puzzles me more than time…and nothing bothers me less, as I never think about [it].” Early Buddhist philosophers did not take the matter so lightly. For them, time as an independent objective entity cannot exist because “distinctions of space and time into past, present and future cannot be made without reference to objects in motion.” Zeno the Stoic, trying to track down time in the 3rd century BC, followed a similar argument to the startling conclusion that even motion cannot exist. Newton’s great assumption which became the basis for Western science is that of a uniform time through which all bodies “move”. This objective notion of time accompanies a subjective feeling of an ever rolling stream or universally trodden path, but this notion is itself far from universal; it is challenged by many voices, not only from the past but the present as well. Anthropologist W.E.H. Stanner quotes an Australian Aborigine: “White man him go different. Him go road belong himself.” Philosopher and theologian Raimon Panikkar understands that the era of historical consciousness, ushered in by the invention of writing, (chron-icles), is not only preceded but underlain by a pre-historical consciousness in which time can be a more rhythmic, even circular, pattern than a linear one. Zen Master Dogen: “It is believed by most that time passes; in actual fact it stays where it is.” “Ridiculous the waste sad time,” mused T.S. Eliot, “stretching before and after.”
It is not only philosophers, artists and mystics who ponder the riddle of time. Some of the most startling discoveries of modern physics have to do with its mysterious and elusive nature. Einstein’s intuitions of a relative, flexible time have now been confirmed experimentally. Hawking and others have taken his theories still further. It appears that as one gets closer and closer to a complete mathematical description of physical reality, time simply drops out of the equations; in short, time does not exist. This assertion is shocking to our “everyday” experience of temporality and is not easily communicated with our language and thought structure which, following Panikkar, is precisely time-oriented and time-conditioned. The insights of artists are often expressed in metaphor and symbol, the intuitions of mystics by paradox and non-verbal communion, and now scientists find themselves struggling with common words, thought patterns and even the very nature of consciousness. If time does not exist in an absolute sense, then neither can causality. Without a well defined “before” and “after” it is impossible to conceive of a latter event being the result of a former one. Mind boggling experiments in quantum physics are in fact being done, in which operations performed at a certain time can “cause” changes in earlier states. “Before” and “after” precipitates, so to speak, only in conjunction with a certain type of awareness or mode of observation; and it is not merely that there is a subjective as well as an objective side to everything, two sides to one coin. There is either no real coin at all or else it is spinning so fast that the two sides are transparent to one another. This reminds us of the Buddhist pratitya-samutpada, the radical relativity of all things including space, time and even a cognitive self. Science, which for centuries has striven to build a picture of objective reality—the world “out there”, has wandered into a world of appearances, permutations and timeless interdependence that is anything but objective. Quantum theory has shown us the universe as a game of chance, and we are both players and played. “We’re the bat swung by the children,” sang Rumi, “we’re the ball and we’re the game.”
Without causality every event becomes spontaneous and unique. Though shapes and forms appear to arise and dissolve in familiar patterns and we are tempted to make predictions on that basis, really we can only guess at probabilities. Furthermore, since this is a participatory universe to its very core, our predictions and guesses are themselves woven into the fabric of reality, affecting its texture, color and design. If the pattern appears sometimes frayed or incomplete, it is only so in a relative sense. If it looks beautiful or meaningful it is testimony to the creative genius of rational intellect, for example, or to a particular aesthetic sensibility but not to an absolute status. To be absolutely logical one would have to determine (as Descartes did not) what caused logic itself. It could be argued that rational thought appeared in Greece just as spontaneously as did spirituality in India. Ironies of history are rarely sweet but the course of Western thought, which set itself against the typical Eastern one, has taken it around the world, in a sense, to encounter ancient wisdom in a new way. Many physicists today believe that logical inquiry has sailed nearly its full course into the realm of relativity and quantum theory, and that exploration of this world of primal chaos, uncertainty and timelessness must include exploration of our own consciousness. Reality is a spontaneous collaboration involving ghost-like substance, shifting space and time frames, and an active participatory awareness. Any purely objective analysis of this collaboration may lead us into what Buddha called “the jungle of theorizing, the tangle of theorizing, the bondage of theorizing and the shackles of theorizing”. Life need not always be felt as a series of nagging questions, it can also be experienced as lila, God’s play, or pure celebration. Historical consciousness is one of many unique improvisations on Reality, pre-historical consciousness yet another…
Driving the point still further, some physicists postulate that from the timeless, primal “quantum stew” not just one or two realities may emerge spontaneously, but an infinity of them. Some of these “worlds” may be very like our commonly accepted one with a certain kind of time and rational framework; some might be unimaginably different. The reality that each person, or culture, experiences is not independent of countless unknown or even unknowable realms. Today we may have chased the elves and fairies from the woodlands, locked angels in museums of mythology and even bound God with chains of reason. But what do we really know about viruses, global warming or psychological illness? We make definitive statements about life in outer space, but we are more than a little nervous about the boundaries of our personal earthly existence. We dream of cloning ourselves to escape mortality, but how rational are we really? Cosmologists now agree with the Buddha and others that substance and time are quirky habits that may disappear just as inexplicably as they arose, and that absolute trust and dependence on such concepts is not warranted. It is entirely possible that the 21st century will see the end of time as we know it. In an historical sense this could well mean environmental disaster, nuclear holocaust or world-wide famine, plaque and depression, although we would rather hope for a kind of realized, perfected “future”. In an ahistorical sense it could mean simply transcending this world of flux and change, much as the Souix ghost dancers would have danced themselves into another world even as they were being shot down by soldiers. Again a more optimistic vision would see history ending in a spontaneous collaboration of all peoples including artists, philosophers and scientists that, being timeless, could not involve fear, greed or regret. But without time even apocalyptic visions, whether optimistic or pessimistic, would be out of place.
Physicists are being led to the conclusion that every view of reality is relative and contingent, that there is no primary substance, absolute meaning, method or time frame to which we can refer. We are enmeshed in a four-dimensional space-time pattern in which everything that we feel as our past, present and future exists en bloc. Observation of this total reality, or any particular mode of perception, can occur only by slicing it so to speak into three-dimensional sections, each section representing an aspect of the Absolute. The “slicing procedure” developed by early Greek philosophers, modified by Arab and Jewish theologians, then refined by Newton, Descartes and others has given us our 3-dimensional material world and a subjective feeling of a linear, flowing time. Native Americans took a different cross-section, in which at least two of the four directions—East and West—did not come quite clean from time and in which the power of the world, like the Sun moving across the sky is rhythmic and circular. Tatanka-Ptecila, a Souix medicine man, sings:
“In this Circle O ye warriors, Lo I tell you each his future,
All shall be as I reveal it in this Circle.”
Don Juan taught Carlos Casteneda that the universe is an infinite agglomeration of energy fields and that rational perception is a particular choosing or grouping of these fields. “Time, space and causation,” wrote Vivekananda, “are only like a glass through which the Absolute is seen.” Infinite, unconditioned Reality, like the primal quantum state of modern physics, is original not just in a temporal sense but as a timeless basis for perception itself. Raimon Panikker hearkens a trans-historical consciousness, in which the past and future are integrated into a tempiternal present. Angelus Silesius wrote:
“Do not compute Eternity as year after year,
One step across time, Eternity is here.”
“History is now,” said Eliot, the sense of time being only a detail in the over-all pattern. “Time past and time future point to one end, which is eternally present.” From this standpoint then, how can we view and evaluate our personal past and, more importantly only in a historical sense, how can we envision the 21st century?
In our meditation on time we have glimpsed some radical new (and some very old) insights: That time is not absolute, uniform and changeless—it may curve and twist, revolve in circles, even break and disappear; that, time being relative and subjective, so too is the notion of causality and determinism—spontaneity is at the very source of things; that there is an infinity of possibilities not only vying to become the future but claiming equal status with our past; and that these worlds of possibilities— what might have been and what might be— exist perpetually and interdependently with what has been and what will be. As our rational perception cuts its unique slice in this infinite agglomeration of energies it indeed does so in linear time, but other cuts can be made in other modes and frequencies. Our historical consciousness sees the past as a finished product conditioning a future which is always waiting to happen, while the present is felt as an irresistible one-way motion. If we suffer chronically from a sort of motion sickness it is significant that we seek a cure in dreams of perfection or even immortality in the future, while Native Americans for example sought to “circle back” to a timeless world of their ancestors. In our modern world, the historical past comes alive only in a psychological sense, but as not only mystics have told us but also philosophers and artists and now even modern physicists, this is a narrow vision. As time looses its absolute status our meditation on time becomes a rather Zen-like piercing of the tempiternal moment in which past(s), present(s) and future(s) are all equally infused with vitality and consciousness. Our past, the 20th century, the whole history of mankind is not just like the beginning of a detective novel whose riddle will be solved in the future. The 2nd and 3rd millenniums, “time past and time future”, truly exist, or emerge spontaneously as you would have it, in an illuminated present.
Carlos Casteneda tells of Calixto Muni, the popular hero of the Yaqui Indians, who was executed by Spanish conquerors. “What would you say,” don Juan asked him, “to a story of Calixto Muni the victorious rebel who succeeds in liberating his people?” Carlos replied that that might be an acceptable way of “releasing psychological stress”, but don Juan came back, “The story teller who changes the end of a “factual” account does so at the direction and under the auspices of the spirit. Because his pure understanding is an advance runner probing that immensity out there, [he] knows without a shadow of a doubt that somewhere, somehow, in that infinity, at this very moment the spirit has descended. Calixto Muni is victorious. His goal has transcended his person.” Before our historical consciousness can recoil too much against such re-telling of historical fact, it might be appropriate to remember another story. If a particular son of a simple Jewish carpenter and his devout wife had only been a very great teacher, spiritual leader or political revolutionary; even if, like Calixto Muni, he had died a martyr’s death, that might have been a very great thing historically; but it is doubtful if, on that basis alone, we would now be contemplating the 3rd millennium Anno Domini. It was not historical consciousness that “changed the story” of Jesus from that of a great man to an Eternal Presence. It was not historical consciousness that revealed his “victory” on the cross, that moment of the spirit descending when “his goal transcended his person”. And it could not have been with historical consciousness that Christ himself might have experienced the splitting of the shell of temporality, the breaking of the chains of causality and determinism, revealing his identity with all things, and all beings, past, present and future. We do not need to accept this story either, but as we approach the year 2000 AD it is only fair and rational that we keep it in mind.
Labels: Eco-Philosophy
Ken wrote this piece for The New Gaia Eco-Philosophy magazine, c. 1996Our concern for the well-being of Earth has expressed itself in two major ways. First, by the question, “What can I do?” What concrete action can I take that will contribute to the healing of ‘oikos’, our eco-system, our ‘household’ and its inhabitants? And second, by the question, “How can I be?” How can I change myself in a qualitative way so that my whole being will resonate with and expand the positive forces of life? Pondering the first question leads us to an ecological awareness, and this has exposed and combated many destructive activities such as pollution, squandering of resources, desecration of natural beauty, and so on. Response to the second question impels us toward a spiritual awareness, and such practices as yoga and meditation in their many forms. If ecological thinking addresses mainly ‘what can I do?’, and has not always recognized the need for a spiritual base, it is also true that spirituality, in addressing ‘how can I be?’, has tended to ignore the link between contemplation and action. Ecology has somewhat neglected the healing of the human spirit, while spirituality has too often failed to grapple with the concrete problems of life.
With his concepts of Eco-Yoga and the participatory mind, Henryk Skolimowski has challenged us to bring together these two seemingly opposite approaches, the ecological and the spiritual, action and meditation, the practical and the ideal, and to find a unified answer to the two questions, “What can I do?” and “How can I be?” In the present article we will take up this challenge by considering one spiritual path, expressed by the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali(4th cent. B.C.?), and by attempting to correlate the psychological terms of this ancient discipline with modern ecological concerns. As an integrating factor we will call upon the image of Gaia, the cosmos as a living, feeling, as well as material Being. The goal of Raja-Yoga, as it is called, is enlightenment, or union of the self with Atman, the Universal Self. But, “It is not just the self”, writes Jungian psychologist James Hillman, “but the world which is having nightmares.” If we should not be satisfied with a strictly objective approach to ecological problems, neither can we abide with a purely subjective resolution of spiritual ones. We must find the ‘what can I do?’ in our meditation as well as the ‘how can I be?’ in our action.
“Yoga is restraining the mind from taking various forms”, wrote Patanjali, beginning significantly at the center of the Raja-Yoga path. In fact, pratyahara, or detachment of the mind from objects of the senses, is the fifth of the eight ‘limbs’ of Raja-Yoga, but by starting here we get a subtle reminder. The limbs are not meant merely to be climbed, one after another until the top, the final goal, Atman or enlightenment is reached. Yama and niyama, for example, the first two limbs which are moral injunctions and fixed observances, the do’s and don’ts of Raja-Yoga, are not just means to an end. Truthfulness, non-stealing, self study, etc. are more than just steps along the way; Atman (how can I be?) cannot exist apart from purity of action (what can I do?) This is also true as we formulate Eco-Yoga, but here the converse is even more significant: Right action cannot exist apart from deep realization, and ecological problems will not be solved using exclusively rational tools. Even more so as we begin to see Earth not as inert matter but as Gaia; the yamas and niyamas, our moral and ethical relationship to the world, become a natural expression of the participatory mind.
“Yoga is restraining the mind from taking various forms”, but the rational mind exists precisely in a world of forms. We see a tree, for example, by the mind molding the impulses of the tree into a certain form; the tree becomes a concept. But with the participatory mind, when the Earth is Gaia, when we practice yoga, or Eco-Yoga, we learn to ‘see’ the tree as a living, breathing personality. We see the spirit of the tree. Pratyahara is not shutting off the mind or blocking out the world. It is, however, ‘stopping the world’ in Don Juan’s language, which means checking the mental habit of continuously itemizing, categorizing and interpreting what we behold with our senses. It is the gateway to seeing a world of energy, not just dead form. It is, clearly, seeing not just objectively, seeing not only with our eyes but with another sense, the ‘third eye’, if you will. In terms of Eco-Yoga it is to admit that we as human beings do not have a corner on consciousness, that the cosmos is conscious to its deepest recesses. But how does this kind of vision come about?
In Patanjali’s view the final limbs of Raja-Yoga, concentration, meditation and absorption, can barely be thought of as separate practices. The three together, dharana, dhyana and samadhi, he calls samyana, and these might be felt as three facets of a certain mind-poise which is at once a cause and effect of enlightenment, or realization of Atman. In the context of Eco-Yoga it is con-centration which allows us to ‘be’ at the center; and this center is not our ego, which separates us as subject from object, throws us exactly off-center, but it is Gaia herself, the conscious universe. Meditation is the continuous experience of this center and can be called many things, including Love. Samadhi is beyond describable experience; the center disappears. It is that from which we awake to consciousness, Being and Love. It is that by which we understand and practice yoga, which is holistic, whether we call it yoga, Eco-Yoga or any other name. Wherever we begin, at whatever stage we enter, whether it be with moral injunctions, observances, correct posture, regulation of breath or with meditation itself, each ‘limb’ expands from and ultimately contracts to the ‘root’ which is nothing other than Atman, or Gaia, the total practice and experience of yoga.
How wrong it would be, for example, to think of pranayama, the fourth limb of Raja-Yoga, as merely controlling the breath. For Patanjali, pranayama means not only smoothing and regulating the outer breathing process but harmonizing the entire nervous system. Atman cannot be realized in a state of anxiety or neurosis! Nor can we behold Gaia without letting ourselves melt into her natural rhythms, and these frequencies and attenuations can be experienced in everything from our own heartbeats, our breathing, daily, monthly and even astrological cycles, to the whole span of physical existence. Needless to say, many modern occupations and pre-occupations do not have this soothing effect. Television may be crippling our nervous systems as well as blinding our third eye. Likewise, asana, or correct posture, which is the third limb, implies much more than a physical exercise. In Patanjali’s view, as well as in numerous other meditation practices, it is not possible to make a positive and lasting connection to Atman, or whatever, while the body is in a chronic state of tension (or sloth). In the case of Eco-Yoga it is equally clear. To really ‘see’ a mountain for instance, one must become a mountain, firm and still. This is the vision of Gaia, and it is no accident that most hatha-yoga postures (including tadasana, or the mountain pose) bear the names of natural elements and forces, and living creatures, as well as dieties.
Finally, as we have said before, the first two limbs of Raja-Yoga, the ethical and moral injunctions (what can I do?), do not exist apart from deep spiritual realization (how can I be?) And it should be quite obvious that the corresponding aspects of Eco-Yoga will coincide closely with those of Patanjali’s sutras. Although we could add non-strip-mining and no-deforestation to the traditional yamas, non-killing, non-stealing, etc., this is almost redundant. With the niyamas such as contentment, austerity, study and worship of God we should not have to specify voluntary simplicity, recycling and ecological awareness. And, once again, we remember that these concrete do’s and don’ts are not just the result of a rational decision. It would not be possible by merely calculating material consequences, or even aesthetic costs, of strip-mining or deforestation to fully comprehend the impact of breaking these, so to speak, eco-yamas. One has to actually ‘see’ the mountain or the tree as Gaia, which in this case means nothing less than feeling the very pain of the broken tree or carved mountain as one’s own. This is the true basis for correct (and adequate) ecological action. This is also the self-effacement of the yogi, as well as the agony of Christ and the compassion of the Bodhisattva. This is the Grace of Being as well as that of Action, the fruit as well as each limb of Eco-Yoga. It is at once the answer to both of our questions, “What can I do?” and “How can I be?”
Labels: Eco-Philosophy